Category Archives: * Not recommended

Just a Boy by Rob Clinger

justHaworth Press, 2007     ISBN: 1560236612

Seventeen year old Jove is attracted to some of his male friends, particularly to Jason who lives next door, as well as to a neighbor’s gardener he’s been spying on. He’s relieved that the girlfriend he doesn’t really care about is going away for the summer. Through a series of typical ups and downs over the next few months, Jove comes out, and finally finds himself with the boyfriend he’s wanted all along.

Unfortunately the writing is stilted, and the chapters, at approximately three pages each, are annoyingly short. Oddly, the publisher has chosen to put copyright information at the bottom of the first page of each chapter, and I found that interrupted the flow of the story even more.

Advertisements

Leave a comment

Filed under * Not recommended, 2000s

Bright Purple: Color Me Confused by Melody Carlson

purpleTh1nk Books, 2006 ISBN: 1576839508

Ramie’s best friend since childhood suddenly announces that she’s a lesbian, causing Ramie to flee to the restroom in the mall where she throws up.

Following this extreme reaction, Ramie settles into bigoted religious cant and, despite her mother’s urging that Jessica needs her best friend now more than ever, makes things worse as Jessica’s secret gets out at school. She worries that people will think she is lesbian simply by association and by her participation in girls’ basketball, going so far as to quit the basketball team temporarily.

The attempted suicide of another student who has been teased for being gay is an eye-opener for Ramie, and she starts to realize how much she is hurting Jessica. She and another friend reach out to her, and find that Jessica has been carrying an even deeper secret, one that she desperately needs help for. This event leads to the author having a gay teen didactically quote the statistics for harassment, gay-bashing, and suicide rates among gay teens.

Meanwhile, Ramie convinces her Pastor that the church should hold a forum on the issue of religion and homosexuality. The forum dissolves into lots of shouting, as well as misguided, but well-intentioned attempts by the members of the youth group to show “Christ’s Love” to the gay teens.

Carlson has a heavy-handed agenda, and I don’t think the book will change the minds of Christian teens about homosexuality, nor bring other teens to appreciate the Christian point of view. Too little has been paid attention to Jesus’ message of love and acceptance.

Leave a comment

Filed under * Not recommended, 2000s